Elbow Room: The Varieties of Free Will Worth Wanting (MIT Press) [Daniel C. Dennett] on *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. A landmark book . Daniel Dennett is one of the most fascinating philosophers currently a friend of mine proposed re-reading Elbow Room for his book group. Daniel Dennett, whose previous books include “Brainstorms “and (with Douglas Hofstadter) “The Mind’s I, ” tackles the free will problem in a highly original an.

Author: Moogugis Tojadal
Country: Angola
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Finance
Published (Last): 11 February 2009
Pages: 408
PDF File Size: 9.35 Mb
ePub File Size: 3.63 Mb
ISBN: 334-4-23548-730-5
Downloads: 24192
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Dukasa

See Dawkinspp. The way out of this kind of dilemma, though, is to realize that we really want when we say that we could have the ability to do otherwise is just to say that in a similar situation, we could have acted differently, and we don’t really care that it’s the same.

The chapter “Could Have Done Otherwise” finally takes the lid completely off the metaphysical “can” of worms Dennett is fond of the occasional pun. Since we have no way of performing this experiment, this question is a long-term classic in philosophy and physicists have tried to interpret the results of other experiments in various ways in order to figure out the answer to this question.

These same deliberators, to whom daniiel are so important, may not care much just how a dog barks when it does.

Daniel C. Dennett

He start with an entire chapter on why we don’t want to think denmett free will. But I cannot shake that “feeling” that I am a free person. This is an very good and somewhat unusual analysis of the question of Free Will. Retrospective desires to change the past, wanting to be able to make several incompatible choices at once, confusion about the difference between the actual and the possible, the role of chaos in physics — these are just a few caniel the things considered.

Paperbackpages. But the fact of the matter is that if our minds were in exactly the same state as that time, and we proceeded to act in the same way, it would be impossible, in the exact same situation to act differently than we did. The practive of keeping your head down AFTER hitting the ball still can have an effect how you behave before hitting it.


Fletcher Professor of Philosophy at Tufts University.

That is the point of this book. If an experimenter interrupts one of these steps the wasp will repeat that step again. What does it mean to make a choice?

Dennett then invites all who are satisfied with this level of analysis to get on with living while he proceeds into the deeper hair-splitting aspects of the free will issue.

This book is written in a fairly airy style, a little less down to Earth than his later writing. Then he points out that when many people talk about having even “free-er” will than we already seemingly have, they are talking about the ability to make contradictory choices or disobey other physical laws. Value Theory categorize this paper. This is one of my favorite books of all time. I did find that this book was a little harder to follow even more-so than some of dsniel other pieces because Dannett, to me, seems to write in a style that almost mimics free-form.

How can we have free will if we do not have indeterministic choice?

Daniel C. Dennett, Elbow Room – PhilPapers

In discussing what people are and dwniel free will matters to them, Dennett makes use of an elboow perspective. It could be argued that this is because I find his ideas congenial, but in fact the causality is the other way around: Again, Dennett’s argument is that we may not have behavioral choice, but we do have control of our behavior.

I mention this in passing, not as a criticism. Consciousness Explained as it covers many of these same topics.

Dennett spends half his time making the case for determinism, and the other half laying out the argument for why it’s really not that scary. It seems more like a takedown of any argument FOR free will.

For Dennett, the ebow to this question is, no, not really. I “feel” like I have free will, just like everyone else.

Thanks for telling us about the problem. In the most specific circumstance actual eventshe suggests there is only one option left to us. You couldn’t have done it another way. This goes all the way up from the movement of the planets all the way down to how the cells in your mother’s uterus divided to make you.


Aug 14, David rated it really liked it. Jan 03, Chris is currently reading it. We would be worse off if we did not do so. Science Logic and Mathematics.

Dennett is a noted atheist, avid sailor, and advocate of the Brights move Daniel Clement Dennett III is a prominent philosopher whose research centers on philosophy of mind, science, and biology, particularly as they relate to evolutionary biology and cognitive science. How can we hold people responsible and punish them for their behaviors if they have no choice in how they behave? This is Dennett’s earlier attempt to clarify philosophical thinking on the topic of free will. But of what use would such a theoretical possibility be?

Elbow Room (book) – Wikipedia

As bad as it gets. It goes on to analyze concepts of control and self-control-concepts often skimped by philosophers but which are central to the questions of free will and determinism.

Nov 10, Billie Pritchett rated it liked it Shelves: Sanford – – Philosophy Dennett is able to accept determinism and free will at the same time. An oldie from the mid 80’sbut a goodie. Dennett was as refreshingly pro-science as he always is and I especially liked his main argument that the main reason philosophers think we don’t have free will is that their image of what they want free will to be is inc I’m a big fan of Daniel Dennett – he’s one of the more amusing philosophers in terms of his writing, he’s always provocative and interesting, and I mostly dennettt with what he says.